Judge sends New York's Kalshi case back to state court, and Kalshi warns of a shutdown
U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick on November 19 sent New York Attorney General Letitia James's gambling suit against Kalshi back to state court. Kalshi's lawyers say a renewed restraining order there could halt its exchange nationwide.
Spread, covering prediction markets, crypto and trading
, 2 min read
111 daysCase spent in federal court, July 31 to November 19
What to know
- Judge Vernon Broderick (S.D.N.Y.) found no federal subject-matter jurisdiction and remanded the New York AG's July 31 suit against Kalshi to state court in Manhattan.
- He denied the state's request for fees, finding Kalshi's grounds for removal objectively reasonable.
- Kalshi asked Justice Melissa Crane for a status conference and a chance to respond before any renewed restraining-order application, arguing an order could reach customers nationwide.
Kalshi is a New York company. That one fact turns an ordinary jurisdiction ruling into a problem for every Kalshi customer, wherever they live.
On November 19, U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick sent New York Attorney General Letitia James's gambling suit against Kalshi back to the state Supreme Court in Manhattan. James filed it on July 31 and Kalshi removed it to federal court the same day. Broderick found the federal court had no subject-matter jurisdiction. According to Gaming.net's account of the opinion, he held that Kalshi's status as a CFTC-designated contract market is a defense to the state's claims, not a reason to hear them in federal court, and that a federal Wire Act question in the complaint was real but not substantial enough. He refused the state's request for fees, calling Kalshi's removal arguments objectively reasonable.
Why "from New York" matters
The case now goes back to Justice Melissa Crane, who earlier denied the attorney general's bid for emergency relief as moot after the removal. The state can ask again. Kalshi's lawyers at Milbank moved first: in a late-night letter, described by crypto.news from gaming lawyer Daniel Wallach's account, they asked Crane for an immediate status conference and a chance to respond before she rules on any renewed request, and argued the state hasn't shown an emergency that justifies an order without hearing from Kalshi.
The heart of their letter is scope. The restrictions New York sought cover event contracts offered "within or from New York," and Kalshi runs its exchange from New York. Read literally, that's not geofencing one state. It's switching off the venue. Milbank also argued the order could force positions to be liquidated, and that the request's catch-all for other events is loose enough to catch Kalshi's financial and economic contracts, not only sports.
That's what makes New York different from Louisiana, where a state judge's order told operators to block Louisiana customers. Kalshi can geofence a state it doesn't live in. It can't geofence its own headquarters.
The money on the table
Crypto.news calls it a $36 billion lawsuit but doesn't say how that figure is built, and Gaming.net's account of the complaint describes only injunctions. Treat the number as unexplained. What crypto.news does report is that the state seeks penalties, restitution and forfeiture of profits, and that Milbank's letter cites $178 billion in annualized trading volume and a $22 billion valuation, figures it says come from the attorney general's own filings. That valuation is already stale: Kalshi was in talks at $65 billion this month.
Federal courts haven't been friendly either. Judge Analisa Torres denied Kalshi a preliminary injunction against New York in July, and the Fourth Circuit ruled against it in Maryland on November 18. Remand moves the fight to the court the state picked. The next date that matters is whenever Crane schedules that conference, and whether she hears Kalshi before she rules on a new restraining order.
This article is general information. It is not investment advice, and trading involves the risk of losing money.
Sources
- Kalshi moves to block New York restraining order as $36 billion lawsuit returns to state court, crypto.news, November 20, 2026
- Kalshi's New York Gambling Case Moves Back to State Court, Gaming.net, November 20, 2026
- Kalshi Says Proposed New York Order Could Shut Exchange, The Defiant, November 20, 2026
Written by an AI correspondent under standards set by editor Jacob Knight. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will fix it.