Kivorent News

Friday, November 20, 2026

MarketsNews

Judge warns CFTC of a steep climb in its bid to stop Utah's Kalshi cases

US District Judge Robert Shelby heard the CFTC's request on November 20 to block Utah from enforcing its gambling laws against Kalshi and other prediction markets, signaled doubt, and set no date for a ruling.

Spread, covering prediction markets, crypto and trading
, 3 min read

1%Utah's share of Kalshi's market, per the state

What to know

  • Judge Robert Shelby heard the CFTC's injunction request against Utah on Friday, November 20, and gave no timeline for a ruling, according to FOX 13.
  • Shelby already ruled for Utah in Kalshi's own suit in August; Kalshi's appeal is at the Tenth Circuit.
  • Utah charged Kalshi and its two co-founders with 13 felonies and one misdemeanor in late October.

The federal government's case against Utah landed in front of the one judge who has already told Kalshi no, and on Friday he sounded ready to say it again.

US District Judge Robert Shelby opened the hearing on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's request for an injunction by saying the agency may have "a steep hill to climb," FOX 13 Utah reported. The CFTC wants Shelby to stop Utah from enforcing its anti-gambling laws against federally regulated prediction markets, Kalshi first among them. Shelby took arguments and gave no timeline for a ruling.

Same judge, second round

This is the second time Shelby has had the question in front of him. In August he granted summary judgment to Utah in the suit Kalshi itself filed in February, finding that federal commodities law did not stop the state from enforcing its gambling statutes. The Tenth Circuit refused to pause that ruling in September, and Kalshi's appeal is still pending in Denver.

What changed since August is who is asking. Utah Attorney General Derek Brown filed a civil suit against Kalshi on October 20. A week later the CFTC sued Utah, arguing that federal law gives the agency exclusive authority over contracts traded on exchanges it registers, according to Covers. The day after that, Utah indicted KalshiEX and co-founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara on 13 felonies and one misdemeanor tied to offering gambling in the state, according to a write-up by tax practitioner Russ Fox. Those founders are due to face the state charges next month.

A federal regulator arguing preemption carries more weight than a company arguing it, which is the whole point of the CFTC's state-by-state campaign. It has now sued a dozen states, including Louisiana and Arkansas. Friday's hearing suggests a change of plaintiff doesn't change Shelby's reading of the statute. Gambling regulation, he said in court, sits "squarely within the police powers of the state."

What Utah is actually fighting over

The state's lawyer told the court Utah makes up about 1% of Kalshi's total market, FOX 13 reported. That small number is the tell. Kalshi isn't fighting for Utah's revenue. It's fighting a criminal case against its founders and a precedent that the 43 attorneys general who asked the CFTC to drop its sports-swap proposal this month would cite the day it lands.

CFTC attorney Jordan Minot pushed the other way, telling the court Utah's ban reaches well beyond sports contracts. That matters for the agency's argument: the broader the state's reach into contracts on elections, weather or economic data, the easier it is to call it interference with federal markets rather than ordinary gambling enforcement.

Utah has no legal sports betting market, TradeHandle noted after the August ruling, so there's no licensed alternative for a bettor in Salt Lake City either. Other prediction market operators have already pulled out of the state, FOX 13 reported.

The split keeps widening

A Shelby ruling for Utah would put a district court squarely against the agency itself, not just against Kalshi, while appeals courts are already divided. The Fourth Circuit sided with Maryland this week, a split Reuters said raises the odds the Supreme Court takes up the question. For traders in Utah, nothing changes until someone rules: the state's cases against Kalshi stay live, and other operators have already left.

The question nobody answered on Friday is the one that matters most to Kalshi's founders. If Shelby denies the CFTC, does the federal government seek emergency relief from the Tenth Circuit before the criminal case moves forward? The agency hasn't said. For how the contracts at the center of this fight are priced, see our explainer on prediction market prices.

This article is general information. It is not investment advice, and trading involves the risk of losing money.

Sources

Prediction markets

Written by an AI correspondent under standards set by editor Jacob Knight. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will fix it.