Kivorent News

Friday, November 20, 2026

MarketsNews

43 state attorneys general tell the CFTC its sports swap rule is out of bounds

Attorneys general from 43 states and Washington, D.C., led by Ohio's Andy Wilson, filed a comment asking the CFTC to withdraw its proposal to define sports and other event contracts as swaps. They argue the agency lacks the authority and, with one commissioner, the quorum to adopt it.

Spread, covering prediction markets, crypto and trading
, 2 min read

44Attorneys general on the letter (43 states plus D.C.)

What to know

  • A bipartisan group of 43 state attorneys general and D.C.'s attorney general filed a comment asking the CFTC to withdraw its October proposal defining event contracts as swaps.
  • The letter, co-led by Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson, says the CFTC is claiming power Congress never gave it over sports betting.
  • The states also argue a one-member commission cannot adopt the rule; Chair Michael Selig has run the agency alone while two nominees await Senate votes.

The CFTC wants a rule that says a bet on Sunday's game is a swap. Nearly every state attorney general in the country just told it, in writing, that saying so doesn't make it true.

Attorneys general from 43 states and the District of Columbia filed a comment asking the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw its October 9 proposal, which would add event contracts on sports, politics, culture and weather to the federal definition of a swap. Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson co-led the letter. Sports Betting Dime, which reported 44 signers counting D.C., lists Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah among them, with 35 more states joining. "A sports bet isn't a derivative just because the CFTC says so," Wilson said, as quoted by Sports Betting Dime.

The comment window on the proposal closed November 18, as we reported. It isn't the states' first pass: a coalition of 44 attorneys general also wrote to the CFTC in July, against its earlier event-contract proposal.

The quorum argument

The states make two claims. The first is the one they have made all year: the Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC no power over sports wagering, and federal appeals courts have refused to read it that way. The Fourth Circuit's 2-1 ruling against Kalshi in Maryland on November 18 is now the freshest example they can point to.

The second is newer and narrower. According to Casino.org, the attorneys general argue a commission with one sitting member cannot adopt the rule at all, because a quorum takes at least two commissioners and perhaps as many as four. Chair Michael Selig has run the CFTC alone. President Trump nominated Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland to two open seats on November 12, and neither has been confirmed.

That second argument is the one to watch. A statutory-authority fight goes to the merits and could take years to settle. A quorum challenge is procedural, cheap to bring and, if a court buys it, would sink the rule no matter how good the CFTC's reading of the statute is. It also sets a clock: if Anonick and Rowland are confirmed before the agency votes on a final rule, the objection mostly goes away.

Who is on the other side

Selig's position hasn't moved. He has called event contracts commodity derivatives inside the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction, and the agency has spent November suing states that disagree, including Louisiana and, with the Justice Department, Arkansas. In Louisiana alone, Legal Sports Report counted four separate lawsuits and two restraining-order fights within a week.

A comment letter can't stop a rule. What it does is build the record a court will read when a state sues over the final version, and 44 signatures tell the CFTC that suit is coming. The proposal's job was to give federal judges a definition to defer to. With a single-member commission and most states lined up against it, the open question is whether the agency finalizes it before its two new commissioners are seated, or waits and takes the quorum issue off the table.

This article is general information. It is not investment advice, and trading involves the risk of losing money.

Sources

Prediction marketsTrading basics

Written by an AI correspondent under standards set by editor Jacob Knight. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will fix it.