Federal judge won't stop New York's Kalshi hearing, now set for Monday
U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield on Friday refused the Trump administration's emergency request to keep a New York state judge from ruling on Attorney General Letitia James's bid to restrain Kalshi. Justice Melissa Crane set a hearing for Monday.
Spread, covering prediction markets, crypto and trading
, 3 min read
1.2MNew Yorkers who use Kalshi, per the company
What to know
- Judge Lorna Schofield denied the administration's emergency request, made at a Friday telephone hearing, to stop Justice Melissa Crane from ruling on New York's restraining-order application, ABC News reported.
- Crane, of the state Supreme Court in Manhattan, set a hearing on the application for Monday, November 23.
- Kalshi's lawyer told Crane a restraining order would likely force it to liquidate all open positions; the CFTC argued in federal court it would shut Kalshi down nationwide.
The federal government asked one Manhattan judge to stop another from ruling, and lost. That leaves Kalshi's fate in New York with a state court on Monday, and the people with the most at stake are traders holding open positions who have no seat in either courtroom.
On Friday, the Trump administration asked U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield, at an emergency telephone hearing, to keep Justice Melissa Crane of the state Supreme Court from ruling on Attorney General Letitia James's request for a temporary restraining order against Kalshi. ABC News reported Schofield's answer in full: "The requested application is denied." Crane has set a hearing on the order for Monday, November 23.
The case only reached Crane two days earlier. As we reported, U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick sent James's July suit back to state court on November 19 (/stories/kalshi-new-york-case-remanded-state-court). The state asked for a restraining order again on Friday, according to ABC.
What the order would reach
James wants Kalshi to stop offering sports contracts without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission. Her suit also targets contracts on New York college teams and trading by anyone under 21. The proposed order would bar the activity both in New York and from New York, the New York Post reported, and Kalshi is headquartered in New York. That second word is the whole fight. Read the way Kalshi reads it, it reaches a customer in Ohio trading on an exchange run out of New York.
In court on Friday, Kalshi lawyer Sean Murphy told Crane an order would likely force Kalshi to liquidate every open position, with effects well beyond the state, ABC reported. In Schofield's courtroom, CFTC attorney Andrew Weisberg argued a restraining order would shut Kalshi down nationwide. The state's lawyer, Kate Rhodes Janofsky, told Crane there was no evidence of market disruption.
The stakes in Kalshi's own filing are large. Its Milbank lawyers cited $178 billion in annualized trading volume and a $22 billion valuation, the Post reported, and a company spokesperson said 1.2 million New Yorkers use Kalshi. The state's case seeks $36 billion in compensatory damages on top of restitution and penalties, according to The Defiant.
Caught between two orders
Here's the bind nobody has resolved. On August 11 the CFTC issued an emergency order telling Kalshi to keep operating under federal rules, warning that a sudden shutdown could threaten the company's existence, per the Post. If Crane grants James's order on Monday, Kalshi would face a state court telling it to stop and a federal regulator telling it to continue. Liquidating positions means closing contracts before their events settle, at whatever price the book offers. A trader holding a contract at 70 cents that would have paid $1 gets the 70 cents, or less, and loses the bet they chose to make. Our explainer on how these prices work covers why that's not the same as a refund (/stories/how-prediction-market-prices-work).
It has been a bad week in court for the argument that the CFTC alone regulates these contracts: the Fourth Circuit ruled for Maryland (/stories/fourth-circuit-kalshi-maryland-ruling), a federal judge in Utah sounded skeptical (/stories/cftc-utah-hearing-judge-shelby-kalshi), and now two federal judges in New York have declined to keep the state's case away from a state judge. Monday's question is narrower but more immediate: whether Crane writes the order the way the state drafted it, the word from included.
This article is general information. It is not investment advice, and trading involves the risk of losing money.
Sources
- Administration tries to intervene after Kalshi is threatened with restraining order, ABC News, November 20, 2026
- Kalshi warns Letitia James' lawsuit could shut down its $22B business nationwide, New York Post, November 20, 2026
- Kalshi Says Proposed New York Order Could Shut Exchange, The Defiant via Crypto News, November 20, 2026
Written by an AI correspondent under standards set by editor Jacob Knight. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will fix it.