When HIPAA covers your health app data, and when it does not
HIPAA protects health data held by doctors, hospitals, insurers and their vendors, not most apps and wearables people download themselves. Here is where the line falls and which rules apply on the other side of it.
Docket, covering health regulation and AI in care
, 3 min read
60 dayslatest a HIPAA breach notice can reach patients
What to know
- HIPAA applies to covered entities (health plans, clearinghouses and most health care providers) and to the business associates that handle data for them.
- A fitness tracker or symptom app a consumer downloads on their own is usually outside HIPAA, even when it holds medical information.
- Outside HIPAA, the Federal Trade Commission's rules and a growing set of state health privacy laws do most of the work.
The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, usually called HIPAA, is the law most people think protects their health information. It does, but only in certain hands. Whether a heart rate reading, a lab result or a chat with an AI symptom checker is covered depends less on what the data is than on who holds it and why.
Who HIPAA covers
HIPAA's privacy, security and breach notification rules apply to two groups.
- Covered entities: health plans, health care clearinghouses, and health care providers that bill or send other standard transactions electronically. In practice that includes nearly every hospital, clinic, pharmacy and insurer.
- Business associates: companies that create, receive or store protected health information on a covered entity's behalf, such as a billing service, a cloud host, an electronic health record vendor or an AI scribe working for a clinic. They must sign a business associate agreement and follow the security rule.
The rules are enforced by the Office for Civil Rights at the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). HIPAA gives patients no right to sue under the law itself; enforcement comes through complaints, investigations and settlements.
Where the line falls for apps
The same kind of app can land on either side of the line.
- Inside HIPAA: a hospital's patient portal app, a telehealth service run by a medical practice, or a remote monitoring device a doctor's office gives a patient and reads on its behalf. Medicare pays for many of those monitoring programs, as our remote patient monitoring explainer describes.
- Outside HIPAA: a step counter, sleep tracker, period tracker or smart ring a person buys and sets up themselves, with no health care provider or plan involved.
A common surprise: when a patient uses their HIPAA right of access to send their records from a hospital to an app of their choosing, the hospital's duty ends at the handoff. If that app is not working for a covered entity, the copy in the app is no longer protected by HIPAA.
FDA status does not decide the question either. An app can be a cleared medical device and still sit outside HIPAA, or be a general wellness product inside it. The FDA rules on safety and claims; for how those categories work, see our explainer on clearance, approval and De Novo.
What applies outside HIPAA
Consumer health apps are not unregulated. The Federal Trade Commission can act against companies whose privacy practices are deceptive or unfair under the FTC Act, for example by sharing health data with advertisers after promising not to. Its Health Breach Notification Rule requires vendors of personal health records that are not covered by HIPAA to tell users, the FTC and sometimes the media when health data is disclosed without permission. The FTC updated that rule in 2024 to state plainly that it reaches health apps.
States add more. Washington's My Health My Data Act, passed in 2023, requires consent before most collection or sharing of consumer health data and lets people sue. Several other states have similar laws or health provisions in broader privacy laws.
Breach notices
Under HIPAA, a covered entity must notify affected people without unreasonable delay and no later than 60 days after discovering a breach of unsecured health information. Breaches affecting 500 or more people must also be reported to HHS, which lists them publicly.
Why it matters
As AI tools, wearables and direct-to-consumer telehealth handle more medical information, the question of who holds the data decides which rules apply, who enforces them, and what a person can do if something goes wrong. Before connecting records to an app, it is worth reading whether the company says it is acting for a provider or plan, or on its own. AI scribes show how the lines overlap: our explainer on when scribes count as medical devices covers the FDA side of tools that also fall under HIPAA.
This article is general information about how technology works. It is not medical advice. Talk to a clinician about your own health.
Digital health and AI in careWearablesFDA and health regulation
Written by an AI correspondent under standards set by editor Jacob Knight. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will fix it.