Apple will stand trial in Paris over claims it blocked independent iPhone repairs
French prosecutors have sent Apple to trial in Paris on charges of obstructing the repair and refurbishment of iPhones, AFP reported Nov. 17. The four-day trial starts June 17, 2027, and covers models from the iPhone XS to the iPhone 15 series.
Bezel, covering phones, computers and the platforms on them
, 3 min read
June 17, 2027Start of Apple's four-day repair trial in Paris
What to know
- Paris prosecutors will try Apple Distribution International and Apple Inc. for obstructing iPhone repair and refurbishment between November 2021 and July 2024, according to AFP.
- The case began with a December 2022 complaint by the French group Halte à l'obsolescence programmée (HOP).
- Apple told AFP it strongly contests the allegations.
If you've ever swapped an iPhone screen or battery at a mall kiosk and then watched Face ID quit or the battery health readout go blank, a French criminal court is about to decide whether that was a security feature or an offence.
Paris prosecutors will put Apple Distribution International and Apple Inc. on trial on June 17, 2027, for obstructing the repair and refurbishment of iPhones, AFP reported on Nov. 17, citing a source close to the case. The hearing is set for four days. iThinkDifferent reports a procedural hearing on Feb. 25, 2027, will fix the trial schedule.
What prosecutors say Apple did
The case covers November 2021 to July 2024. According to AFP's account, Apple configured iPhone software so that phones repaired outside its authorised network could not be fully repaired or refurbished. The mechanism is what repair shops call parts pairing: screens, batteries and cameras carry serial numbers tied to the phone, and the operating system checks them. Swap the front camera at an unapproved shop and Face ID stops working; swap the battery and the battery health feature fails, according to Euronews and blue News.
The model list in Euronews and The Connexion runs from the iPhone XS through the iPhone 12, 13, 14 and 15 series, plus the 2022 iPhone SE.
The complaint came from Halte à l'obsolescence programmée (HOP), a French campaign group, in December 2022. HOP says the faults appear even after repairs with identical original Apple parts when Apple hasn't approved the repair, iThinkDifferent reports. France has made obstructing repair a specific offence since 2021, which is why this is a criminal trial rather than a regulator's fine.
What it could cost, and Apple's answer
The penalty is a fine of up to €300,000, or a share of annual revenue, plus whatever damages customers claim. Euronews puts the revenue cap at 5%, which it estimates at about €21.7 billion. No report says what prosecutors will ask for.
Apple told AFP: "We strongly contest these unfounded allegations." Its long-running defence of parts pairing is security. In 2024 John Ternus said Apple doesn't enable third-party Face ID and Touch ID modules because it can't validate their security, iThinkDifferent notes.
The strongest point for Apple, and the weak one
Apple has moved since the charged period. It launched Self Service Repair in France and seven other European countries in December 2022 and has since said it would accept used genuine parts in repairs. HOP itself says Apple has loosened serialization on newer iPhones, while adding that the changes still need checking over time. The iPhone 16 and later aren't on the charge sheet.
The weak point is the one HOP keeps pressing: a security argument covers a fingerprint sensor, but it is harder to stretch over a battery percentage. That gap is what a judge will have to rule on.
Apple has been here before in France. It paid €25 million to settle a case over not telling users that software updates could slow older iPhones; Euronews dates that settlement February 2021 and blue News February 2020.
For owners, nothing changes before the trial. The practical context is the parts Apple now sells directly: we reported this week that iPhone Duo repair parts went on sale with the inner display at $999. Repair access also shapes what an old phone is worth when you trade it in and how long it stays useful before it reaches end of support. The open question is whether a French verdict, whichever way it goes, ends up rewriting Apple's repair rules beyond France.
Sources
- Apple faces Paris trial over alleged planned obsolescence of iPhones, Khaleej Times (AFP), Nov 17, 2026
- Apple to face landmark trial in France over alleged planned obsolescence of iPhones, Euronews (with AFP), Nov 17, 2026
- Apple to stand trial in Paris over accusations of planned obsolescence, The Connexion, Nov 17, 2026
- Apple faces Paris trial in June 2027 over iPhone repair limits, iThinkDifferent, Nov 17, 2026
- Apple is alleged to have deliberately prevented iPhone repairs, blue News (Keystone-SDA, AFP), Nov 17, 2026
Written by an AI correspondent under standards set by editor Jacob Knight. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will fix it.